Mechanical vs. fixed blade broadheads for crossbows – which one is better? Well, better is a matter of preference and opinion. It varies from person to person. This never-ending broadhead debate starts from the very beginning of bowhunting.
If you are looking for reliability, pick a fixed head. Or, if you want to take the risk, go with a mechanical head.
The broadhead manufacturing companies bring new technologies day-by-day and updated their design. So, both types of broadheads include many advanced features to deliver solid performance. Our motive to present this article to deliver you a clear idea to make your buying decision a bit black and white.
Let’s see – which one goes better for crossbows!
Mechanical broadhead – Awesome Accuracy!
Some hunters love to use mechanical broadhead, and some of them don’t. But you cannot overlook its devastating result. Mechanical blade broadhead ensures massive entrance wound channel and blood trail with same field point accuracy.
Talking about field point accuracy, YES! It is a deadly package. The mechanical head is more accurate and aerodynamic.
This broadhead has a low profile design so that it can fly in the air. After hitting the animal, the blade head starts to expand and begin cutting. It will turn into a faucet if you shot it in the right area.
Variant range and designed mechanical broadheads (such as NAP, Swhacker) are available in the store now.
Fixed blade broadhead – Amazing Reliability!
A fixed blade broadhead has been used since the dawn of bow hunting season. The fixed blade head comes in all shapes. Smaller cutting diameter helps in arrow flight and kills more animals. Many companies have introduced different new designs and technologies to their fixed blade heads.
This broadhead has been considered an easy solution for bow hunting. As there are no moving parts and its blades cannot move, they attach to the ferrule. Their arrowhead always remains in a fixed position.
These blades either attach ferrule or having a replaceable blade. Returning from adventure, clean up the blades, and replace them with freshly sharp ones.
Another plus point, fixed blade broadhead comes with a very durable and reliable design ensuring great penetration.
Mechanical vs Fixed Blade Broadheads for Crossbows – An Ultimate Battle!
An on-going non-stop battle on the fixed blade and mechanical broadheads will never end. With advanced top-notch designs, high-end features, and styles, both broadheads have gained much fame and popularity. Both of them have shown great improvements in their areas.
Aerodynamics
Mechanical broadheads are more aerodynamic than fixed blade broadheads for their low profile blade design. Their blades have designed to seat tightly until they are deployed.
Durability
In terms of durability, fixed blades are more durable than mechanical broadheads, and they can be reused. However, mechanical broadheads also come in a well-built design, but they are not so durable as fixed blade broadheads.
Penetration
Though many experts say – penetration is not a big issue with high-speed bows. But if you prefer deep penetration and reliable performance, nothing can beat the fixed blade broadheads.
Cutting diameter
The fixed blade broadhead does not have a larger cutting diameter. However, most of the mechanical broadheads come with a wide cutting diameter to create massive blood trails. Larger cutting diameter is a must to create a massive entrance wound channel and great blood trails.
Deer recovery rates
Talking about the deer recovery rates, Andy Pedersen, Indian head employee of Maryland’s naval support facility, collected many data. Pedersen reports fixed blade broadheads to have an 82% deer recovery rate, and mechanical broadheads have a 91% deer recovery rate.
Which to choose for crossbows?
At first, you should know crossbows shoot with high speed. So, a fixed blade head with a wider cutting diameter may affect your accurate shots.
As crossbows shoot faster, so they require more power. Sometimes it can affect the mechanical heads, which cannot be able to withstand this additional force.
Suppose you go with a fixed blade, though it may affect the accuracy. But if you can overcome this accuracy obstacle, fixed blade heads can be a great choice with deep penetration and wider blades.
Conclusion
Mechanical vs. fixed blade broadheads for crossbows – discussion will go on forever. Wide range of styles, designs, and varieties available for these two types of broadheads. As technology advancements introduced light-weight arrows, fast-speed bows, etc. So, sometimes it becomes harder to select the suitable one for wild hunting.
Hopefully, this article will provide you an idea to make your money invest-worthy. However, you cannot take it lightly. As broadheads do not come with a low price, few people can’t buy different models simultaneously to observe which performs best with their crossbows.
Leave a Reply